How the Body Positive Movement Unintentionally Shames People Who Choose to Lose Weight
I began my journey to body positivity (BP) and self-acceptance almost six years ago. It's been a wild ride, with lots of bumps and bruises. But mostly it's been an amazing experience resulting in the formation of a wonderful community of advocates and friends. And I'm proud to say that I've allowed my views to change and grow as I've learned more about inclusivity and the importance of hearing one another with an open heart and mind.
Admittedly, I've also witnessed and been a part of shaming people in the BP community who openly express their desire to lose weight. The pervading thought seems to be that BP folks who want to lose weight are inherently self-hating and thus negate all the strides the movement has made to be seen and heard. That, and we tend to internalize the choices of others as an attack on us. I get that the space we've created is so special and hard-won, that we've become very protective of it. But we must remember that this movement is based on the idea that ALL bodies are GOOD bodies. The BP movement is about learning to love and accept our bodies and those of others without judgment. So, if we shun people who make a personal decision to lose weight (for whatever reason), then we are hypocrites. Me included.
I know plenty of women who have learned to love themselves because of the movement, and still want to lose weight and do what feels right for their bodies -- and it's OK! I'm a firm believer in health being something you define for yourself. As I've said before, there are people who are fat and healthy, and fat and unhealthy. The same goes for thin people. So if you are fat (or thin), and you don't feel good in your body, then do whatever you need to do to feel good. Don't let anyone, not even the BP movement, shame you into staying where you don't want to be. By the same token, abstain from judging those folks who choose not to lose weight.
I'm bringing this divisive topic up because I've had conversations with many women in the movement who are expressing a desire to lose weight for their own personal reasons, but feel afraid to share it for fear of banishment from a movement that purports to be inclusive.
Let me remind you that people have all sorts of reasons for why they want to lose weight, and frankly, it's their business. Hell, I'm thinking about losing weight because my plantar fascitis is getting increasingly worse (I've tried everything, including orthotics and special shoes, but to no avail). And 30 pounds ago, I didn't experience this problem (for someone who loves to dance, it's a real bummer). Let me also say that at my current weight I can do yoga, have great cholesterol levels, and my blood pressure is normal. So yes, I have health in many areas, but not in others (my feet hurt!!!). And I want to feel fully vibrant: physically, mentally, and spiritually. It's my God-given right, and it's no ones' business but my own.
Side note: For those of you who do want to lose weight, I hope you'll do it sanely and healthily.
My ultimate desire is that the body-positivity movement embrace all forms of self-love and wellness. It may look different for each of us, but at the end of the day, all most of us really want is to feel our best and to be accepted without fear of judgement. Your thin body is no better than mine. My fat body is not more worthy than yours. And my desire to lose a few pounds so I can dance without achy feet is no reflection of your personal choices.
Being inclusive can only strengthen our cause. So, can we just open our hearts and mind a little more and make space for everyone to feel supported and seen? I sure hope so.